How leadership capacity is cultivated is one of the central challenges for those who seek to create a vibrant democratic society. Roger Geiger's
The History of American Higher Education provides considerable background about how education was used in the early days of America to cultivate leaders and how it has expanded to nurture broader leadership among its citizens in the modern day.
There are a number of commendable attributes of Geiger’s
The History of American Higher Education:
Learning and Culture from the Founding to World War II (2015). The two
things that are most helpful are 1) that the essence and sequence of the entire
book is nicely summarized in the last chapter which is only 13 pages of the
total 552 and 2) the book recounts the origins and roots of higher education in
ways that reinforce the capacity building role colleges and universities played
in building the embryonic democracy and fledgling economy of America. On the
second point, this book could be helpful to those presently serving at
international higher education sites because it both admonishes and warns
through its historic narrative.
There are other histories
of American higher education, some of which do a much better job summarizing
the breadth of higher education rather than what Geiger does, which is to
address the way issues of academic or intellectual insight were cultivated over
time. The recounting of intellectual history is important for educators to
understand, particularly because this history heavily impacts perspectives and
approaches today. However, it would be very unfortunate if readers believed
that after reading Geiger’s account they knew the essentials of American higher
education history.
One of Geiger’s most important contributions is in
summarizing the trends over time that shaped higher education to be what it is
today. Starting with the medieval trivium of grammar, rhetoric, and logic and
informed by the mental, moral and natural philosophies of Aristotle, early
American colleges were intended to prepare ministers and statesmen for public
service. These colleges appealed to privileged men and learning took place in
intimate encounters of eating, living, and studying together among faculty and
students. As Geiger characterized, “The creation of an independent republic, the
United States of America, presented the founders with the challenge of defining
the nature of its government and the conditions that would allow it to
flourish.” (16% into digital text) “…the survival of republics depended on the
virtue of their citizens – the capacity
of individuals to put the public good – the
res
publica – above their personal interests. For patriots, education seemed
the best means of instilling virtue in the citizenry.” (17% into digital text)
The importance of this mission guaranteed that the states would seek some
degree of control over their colleges, a commitment grasped regardless of the
fact that no public funding had gone into these colleges in the early days.
Early American colleges were all affiliated with one or
another of the religious groups that had immigrated to America to find
religious freedom and pursue a life in a new and developing land. Because they
were among the first institutions in the new country, Geiger prominently
profiles the colleges that would eventually be recognized as the “Ivy League.”
Harvard, Yale, Princeton and Columbia are noted most often as they established
trends, differentiated purposes, and competed for eminence as credible places
of learning. Although King’s College (later to be known as Columbia) was founded
by powerful Dutch Reform families, it was the first to declare that its doors
were open to all Christian believers, and it became the place where the upper
ranks of New York society were cultivated. This purpose of entry into the
emerging American elites was characteristic of most collegians well into the
end of the 19
th century and this social advancement was achieved
through acquisition of connections, character, circumstances, and individual
ability.
American universities were heavily influenced in the early
years by the likes of John Adams and George Washington who connected the role
of education with cultivating republican government. Thomas Jefferson envisioned
a state university (UVa) that offered professional and advanced studies. While
the advocacy of such visionaries resulted in a quick start, higher education
went through various ups and downs throughout the 19
th century,
sometimes the result of politics or economic conditions and sometimes more the
result of the changing and uncertain role played by colleges. Students
themselves also sought to shape their experience, resulting in shifting
perceptions of the role of colleges. Particularly in the middle to late 19
th
century, controlling students’ behavior became increasingly important and this
was commonly accomplished by imposing religious fervor and piety on campus. As
attendance expanded to include students beyond the privileged elite, the types
of institutions to serve them proliferated and resulted in many small colleges
sponsored by different religious groups. The dual purposes of liberal education
versus preparation for work and career emerged as a tension at this time with
some institutions attempting to serve both purposes but others specializing and
offering competing approaches.
Geiger’s history documents many important trends that shaped
American higher education including how institutions opened to female students,
cultural minorities, and students from more humble economic backgrounds. He
also cogently summarizes the trends in types of institutions and their purposes
over time, including the move from elite education for public service to
multifaceted institutions dedicated to liberal education, career preparation,
and advancement of knowledge through research. Citing Edwin E. Slosson’s 1910
Great American Universities, Geiger
offers three categories of universities that reflect the prominent trends in
American higher education – the elite colonial colleges of Columbia, Harvard,
Pennsylvania, Princeton and Yale – the western state universities of
California, Illinois, Michigan, Minnesota, and Wisconsin, - and, the postbellum
new universities of Chicago, Cornell, Johns Hopkins, MIT, and Stanford. (57% of
digital text) However, he primarily describes these trends through the lens of
faculty and the college president. Reference to the emerging presence and role
of Deans of Women and Men as important influencers of campus culture and
learning in the late 19
th and early 20
th century is
superficial and fleeting. And, he completely missed the fact that student’s out
of class experiences were addressed in increasingly formal and scholarly ways
following the American Council on Education’s publication of the “Student Personnel
Point of View” in 1937.
Geiger occasionally mentioned Deans in relation to their
role in controlling students on behalf of the President. He gave credit or blame for the growing
“collegiate” culture to fraternities and athletics asserting that the “unspoken
reality of fraternities was that they attracted students concerned with worldly
success and social status.” (38% through digital text) The lack of recognition
of the role of the student affairs deans as educators is a significant
oversight. In addition, in this reviewer’s perspective the overstatement of the
importance of the role of fraternities in shaping campuses neglects the
important recognition of the growing focus on learning in and out of the
classroom. In fact, Geiger took this lack of recognition to a point of
denigration by saying “…college presidents increasingly defended their purpose
as forming the ‘whole man.…, a rationalization that disguised the bankruptcy of
their educational mission, a surrender of intellect to the ascendant value of
the high collegiate era, which enthroned the principal features of manliness.”
(62% of digital text) He later acknowledged that this collegiate life “had
infused enormous vitality into the student experience. Moreover, it had made
college attractive to a far larger population by promising social advancement
and productive careers.” (67% of digital text) It is the opinion of this
reviewer (and partially supported by Geiger’s text) that the growing importance
of higher education in the post World War years was significantly derived from connecting
research to the advancement of knowledge, the vitalization of the collegiate
experience through in and out of class life, and supported by broadening access
to students from all sorts of backgrounds. These three trends are perhaps the
most important and distinguishing characteristics of American higher education
in the 21
st century.